In Theory:

Steve Burger, a former director of the Assn. of Gospel Rescue Missions, says Americans should not hand out money to homeless people on the street, but to rather donate to local food or shelter agencies. Burger reportedly believes that giving handouts promotes destructive behavior among the homeless.

What do you think?

?

The season of giving is a gift to each of us in itself. It is an opportunity to share with others and be part of uplifting one’s fellow man. Every religious tradition includes giving — for a reason. Giving allows us to offer goodwill and friendship. Saving lives and giving are part of the path to salvation.

Scientologists take pride in volunteering to help their communities through the Volunteer Minister Corps, the American Red Cross (blood drives) and organizations like the Church of Scientology Woman’s Auxiliary.

Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard wrote, “Outflow is holier, more moral, more remunerative and more effective than inflow.”

Outflow is not destructive. Giving money to the homeless at freeway exits or street corners is not harmful and will continue. Many do this with the satisfaction they are doing something to help another. I agree that food and clothing are a more effective donation, and I have often given bottles of water and snack foods rather than money to those who approach me. But from a homeless person’s point of view, would it be more effective to ask for money or hold up a sign, “Help me out. Volunteer in your local soup kitchen.”?

Let’s all be encouraged this season to outflow, whether in an organized or random fashion, to those less fortunate than ourselves.

CATHERINE EMRANI

Volunteer Minister

Glendale Church of Scientology

?

Helping the less fortunate is one of humanity’s greatest virtues.

Steve Burger’s recommendations are sound, with some cautionary notes. First, if the only time you give to the poor is when approached by a panhandler, then I’d encourage you to give your pocket change away in spite of the possible downsides. The substance-abuse problem will not be remedied for the individual or in society with the mere elimination of handouts.

Second, it is not right to paint every beggar with a broad brush label of a drug addict. Addressing poverty should require all of us to step up and get more personally involved by getting to know those who are less fortunate by understanding their circumstances.